Linux.com

Feature: Reviews

Get thin client benefits for free with openThinClient

By Cory Buford on September 19, 2008 (9:00:00 AM)

Share    Print    Comments   

Thin clients reduce hardware costs, offer added security by stripping away storage options, and ease management tasks by storing all configurations on a centralized server. Citrix provides a good solution and is a dominant player in this arena with Citrix Presentation server, but that comes at a price -- about $1,000 for five concurrent connections and about $200 to $300 for each additional concurrent client connection. However, taking the thin client route does not have to be that expensive: openThinClient is an open source thin client server that is absolutely free.

GPLv2-licensed openThinClient, based on an Ubuntu server operating system, uses server components and a management system written in Java for midsize to large organizations. It requires only a PXE (Preboot Execution Environment) boot-capable diskless machine on which to run, so it can run on older computers too underpowered to run the latest desktop operating systems.

OpenThinClient uses its own Lightweight Directory Access Protocol (LDAP) repository or an external Active Directory (AD) directory service to store client configurations, and since its server and management components are Java-based, it runs on any platform that supports Java Standard Edition 6 version 1.6 or later. It uses standard protocols such as Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol (DHCP), Trivial File Transfer Protocol (TFTP), and Network File System (NFS). Before you install it, make sure your firewall allows passage of all necessary protocols.

To ensure it will work in your server environment, first check the recommended server and hardware requirements. The hardware must have at least 500MB of disk space, 1GB of RAM, and one network interface card.

Deploying openThinClient

To get started, download the openThinClient package and extract it to a folder, then start the server using /start-server.sh. If you see a message such as "Jboss (MX micro kernel)" followed by the time it takes to start the server, the startup is successful.

After starting the server you can start to configure it using a browser. Open http://servername:8080 and you should see a link to start the openThinClient manager. Click the link to download and start the manager.

After the initial installation of the openThinClient server you must add a new thin client environment. Click the "Create New Environment" button to start a wizard that walks you through the process. If you use openThinClient's built-in LDAP server, there is not much to configure in the wizard. Indicate the hostname or IP address of the LDAP server and its administrator password. You can leave the settings on the next screen on their defaults, and finish the wizard. Alternatively, you can connect to other LDAP servers or AD, in which case you may have to change some settings, such as domain, schema, and organizational unit.

To add a thin client to the environment, make sure you have a running DHCP server, then boot the client station using PXE. The client will not successfully boot using PXE until an administrator registers it on the openThinClient manager. You will see the MAC address of the client you just attempted to boot on the management console. If you right-click the MAC address you can convert it to a thin client, and also fill in some hardware information about the client if you like. After you add the station, you should be able to boot it as a thin client. Once your thin client is added to the environment, it will appear on the management console. Click to expand it, and you will see options such as location and hardware that you can set to help you manage the device.

The thin client won't be much good unless you also add users and their associated applications. OpenThinClient comes with prepackaged applications for common tasks such as browsing and document viewing. The best process is to create the applications first, assign them to an applications group, and then create users or user groups and associate them with the applications. To check the available applications, go to the Packages tab. The preinstalled package includes a predefined Desktop application that enables you to manipulate or configure the desktop interface when inside the thin client OS. It also includes Remote Desktop Protocol (RDP), Xnest, Firefox, Command Line Utility (CLU), VLC Media Player, and a document viewer. These are the only predefined applications available.

To select another application, right click on the Applications tab, choose New Application, and select from the application package list. After you enter the icon name for the desktop and a description for the application, it will be listed under the Application tab, and you can assign the application to a user or user group. For example, I have an administrator tools group for accessing every application, and a user tools group for limited access to the browser, document viewer, and so forth. A Citrix Presentation Server Independent Computing Architecture (ICA) client is also available for installation if you need to connect to a Citrix server.

The available applications are sufficient for general usage but lacking for tasks such as word processing and office productivity. Fortunately, you can add other applications to the openThinClient package by following a few simple steps. I followed the example, which is to add Skype to the package, and I was able to load Skype into the thin client.

To create a user, enter a username and password. You can edit user properties such as the full name and other contact details of the user, the user's group, and applications. Under the user's Applications Group tab, choose the appropriate group. As with applications, you can create user groups. All properties under a group and applications assigned to the group will be applied to member users. You can also add specific applications to users in addition to those from the applications group.

Normally, if you plan and organize user creation and addition, you will avoid putting the same application on the application group and individual user's applications -- but even administrators make mistakes. Unfortunately, if you add an application that already exists in the user's applications group, two of the same application shortcuts will appear for that user. Perhaps the developers can fix this by removing from the Applications tab the applications that already exist in a user's Applications group. Another minor bug I sometimes encountered with the manager is that when I added or edited some properties, the window display was corrupted. For example, when I closed the dialog window, the window remained visible, and I had to press the close button on the title bar of the window to close it. This is an annoying glitch, especially if it occurs while you are entering properties for a user or an application. You may not know whether the data you entered was saved, so you have to close the window and start over again to be sure.

OpenThinClient supports external NFS storage of configuration and user data. If problems occur, the documentation, although somewhat incomplete, is helpful. For problems and package development, the active forum is even more helpful.

Once you've created the users, clients can boot and log in using openThinClient. Boot-up is fast. Users are presented with the familiar Ubuntu login screen, log in using one of the user accounts, and then see a desktop containing the applications the administrator assigned for that user.

I tried browsing the Web, downloaded some files, viewed some documents, and played videos using VLC Media Player, and everything went smoothly. I tried using RDP, but for some reason it would not start; this could be troublesome for anyone who needs to connect to a Windows environment. You can also use Xnest to access Unix systems remotely, just like RDP, especially for Unix and Linux machines.

Impressions and final thoughts

OpenThinClient is an attractive option for organizations that want to move to a thin client environment without paying a penny. Although the prepackaged applications are somewhat lacking, the ability to integrate other applications works well. Client responsiveness, potentially a problem with thin clients, was fine, but I didn't try to stress-test the server. Despite some glitches, openThinClient seems to be a flexible solution for large environments.

Share    Print    Comments   

Comments

on Get thin client benefits for free with openThinClient

Note: Comments are owned by the poster. We are not responsible for their content.

Get thin client benefits for free with openThinClient

Posted by: Anonymous [ip: 85.216.29.81] on September 19, 2008 03:14 PM
Hi there,
thanks for writing an article about our project, we very apreciate it.
On a sidenote, It would be great if you could tell us what difficulties you experienced with RDP.
Since we didnt notice any problems with it yet.

Best regards
Markus

#

openThinClient vs. LTSP?

Posted by: Scott Dowdle on September 19, 2008 04:04 PM
I haven't set up LTSP but I was actually planning to try the Fedora LTSP LiveDVD beta today and found this article first. I was curious how openThinClient compares? LTSP is a native package set in many distros already including Debian, Fedora, Gentoo, openSUSE, and Ubuntu.

I haven't had a chance to check out the project website for answers but I will ASAP.

#

LTSP is free, too.

Posted by: Anonymous [ip: 162.39.22.226] on September 19, 2008 07:32 PM
LTSP is free, too. Been using it since 2000.

#

Get thin client benefits for free with openThinClient

Posted by: Anonymous [ip: 75.145.180.221] on September 19, 2008 08:50 PM
what's the advantage of doign something like over just running all your serious programs off the server via X forwarding?

#

Re: Get thin client benefits for free with openThinClient

Posted by: biaf on September 20, 2008 11:57 AM
I'd say its two different audiences. Running remote X applications requires that you run your own hardware and OS and having you X server locally.
A thin client boots a remote OS on a lightweight hardware and as running X on that remote server. So the local hardware is only presenting screen from the remote server.
In my mind, a thin client solution is freaking cool and just plain ideal for a office solution, and even at home. Why having hardware power under every desk that would have made most datacenters jealous just a few years ago. Instead having the hardware utilized in a centrally and managing environments centrally. And just adding more power that all can share when needed.
I'm looking at having some kind of thin clients at home, as it works so well in a Linux only situation and we don't play that much 3D games (that is not ideal for a thin clients). Just having one desktop for a local Linux/Windows installation as a "gamestation". We are 2 adults and 2 kids and all run Linux only.
I was already looking at LTSP but will definitely check this out.

#

Re: Get thin client benefits for free with openThinClient

Posted by: Anonymous [ip: 69.129.206.200] on September 22, 2008 03:34 AM
Old machines tend to have hard drive failures. This should bypass those (network boot, no local file storage, rip the hard drive, CD drive, floppy drive out if you like).

#

Get thin client benefits for free with openThinClient

Posted by: Anonymous [ip: 71.180.197.47] on September 20, 2008 07:25 PM
I just went to their wiki and followed their link to the commercial version of openThinClient called Aranto at www.aranto.com I went their to look at the available hardware that they offered but it appears that they are only in German and do not offer an English website. Does anyone know of any companies here in the US that would have thin clients that would work well with openThinClient? thanks.

#

Get thin client benefits for free with LTSP derivatives too

Posted by: Michael Shigorin on September 21, 2008 12:51 PM
In case someone would like Pentium-grade hardware with as low as 16M RAM to perform as thin clients, there's something more modern than good ol' LTSP4.2 -- we called it ALTSP5. ISO images of an installer (English CD, Russian DVD, languages can be changed from defaults anyways), as well as README/RELNOTES, are available here: ftp://ftp.altlinux.org/pub/distributions/ALTLinux/4.0/Terminal/current/iso/

#

Get thin client benefits for free with openThinClient

Posted by: Anonymous [ip: 213.217.201.168] on September 22, 2008 12:16 AM
In many cases you only need a RDP session to a Windows Server, in such cases take a look at cult (http://cult-thinclient.sf.net).

#

Get thin client benefits for free with openThinClient

Posted by: Anonymous [ip: 75.149.52.89] on September 22, 2008 08:18 PM
Isn't this mostly a duplicate effort of the offical LTSP project? What I would love to see happen is for native LTSP packages to get the slick LDAP support out-of-the-box. Other than that, it looks like these are two separate projects that do the same thing. Which isn't a bad thing - I'm sure both can be improved due to experiences both sides have had, and maybe even code merges. Woohoo open source!

#

Re: Get thin client benefits for free with openThinClient

Posted by: Anonymous [ip: 76.31.147.208] on September 24, 2008 09:09 PM
I have been using cheap compaq t30 thin clients with ltsp. It would be interesting to see what openthincleint will do. I would also like to see what it does with old p1 clunkers I used to use as thin clients.

#

Get thin client benefits for free with openThinClient

Posted by: Anonymous [ip: 116.71.158.211] on October 07, 2008 11:40 AM
I Would like to know if its possible to install Linux OS at Fujitsu Siemens Futro S Series Thin Clients as we would like to run some Linux based applications on it but it has a built in Elux OS which is supposed to be embeded Linux system but none of the application are running at it. Any kind of help would be appreciated

#

This story has been archived. Comments can no longer be posted.



 
Tableless layout Validate XHTML 1.0 Strict Validate CSS Powered by Xaraya