Linux.com

Feature: Migration

Library system migrates from Linux -- to more Linux

By Tina Gasperson on October 04, 2006 (8:00:00 AM)

Share    Print    Comments   

The six branches of the Howard County Library system in Maryland provide 300 computers to their clients. This week, every computer has been upgraded from a "homegrown" Linux kernel, to Groovix, an Ubuntu Linux derivative.

Amy Begg De Groff, the library's IT director, says Howard County libraries are well supported by its patrons. "We get very gracious funding from the county residents, but the majority of the money goes to [book] collections and payroll. So the funding just doesn't keep up with our IT needs." Because of that, five years ago, the library was exploring alternatives to Microsoft Windows and its steep licensing fees.

De Groff says the library created and deployed a custom kernel that provided patrons with a browser to search the catalog and access the Internet. They wanted more. "Word processing, instant messaging, sound, video -– they just wanted more, more more," she says. "When they walk in and see a computer, they expect it to function just like it does at home."

The library wanted to grant its patrons' wishes without leaving Linux behind. "We were very committed to open source. We exploring building another kernel or going with a vendor." De Groff says they looked at Userful's DiscoverStation, a popular choice with other public libraries moving to open source software, but "we felt locked down with too many of the options. We didn't like the look of it –- we wanted to offer something as close to XP as possible. And with Userful, what we found is that as we slowly took away functionality, we broke other things."

The other alternative De Groff tested was Groovix, an Ubuntu-based distribution that provides many of the options consumers expect from their desktop experience. "After I saw the Groovix deployment, with RealPlayer and other media support, there was no turning back. We begin piloting in January and it went effortlessly." De Groff tested the operating system on her existing hardware, upgrading the RAM from 128MB to 512MB. "The bulk of them are Dell GX150s with some GX100s," she says. "The newest machines are four years old." De Groff also added GCompris, a GPLed educational software package for children that includes more than 80 games.

De Groff advises other libraries considering a move to open source software to do their homework first. "I recommend an extensive survey of customer activity," she says. "We talked to our staff and they said the customers were searching the catalog. But when we talked to the customers, they said, 'We're reading email and doing online banking.' And then when we tracked hits, 70% of them were to MySpace. They may also be banking and need a secure system, but the audio and video are obviously very important as well. Your feedback from the staff isn't always consistent with the data you're going to generate -– so put it all together and meet all those needs." And don't forget training, De Groff says. "You need to extensively train your front line staff. We did three hours of hands-on, mandatory training."

De Groff says the biggest benefit of the upgrade has been the added functionality at a cost that is a fraction of what licensed proprietary systems would have been. "We spent $2,000 in tech support and $25 system-wide for the software," she says. "The biggest expense was the RAM upgrade, which cost $20,000. Oh, and I bought some T-shirts."

Tina Gasperson writes for some of the most respected publications in the industry. She has been freelancing since 1998.

Share    Print    Comments   

Comments

on Library system migrates from Linux -- to more Linux

Note: Comments are owned by the poster. We are not responsible for their content.

Plugins?

Posted by: Anonymous Coward on October 05, 2006 06:16 AM
The only potential problem I see is the web and plugins. The main one's work (except for the latest flash). But there are a lot of plugins that don't work on Linux. e.g. shockwave.

#

Re:Plugins?

Posted by: Anonymous Coward on October 05, 2006 05:03 PM
do you really think a library need to be able to use shockwave or the latest flash ? Any decent source of information don't use those plugins anyway.

#

Re:Plugins?

Posted by: Anonymous Coward on October 05, 2006 09:05 PM
"De Groff says the library created and deployed a custom kernel that provided patrons with a browser to search the catalog and access the Internet. They wanted more. "Word processing, instant messaging, sound, video -– they just wanted more, more more," she says. "When they walk in and see a computer, they expect it to function just like it does at home.[emphasis mine]""

So the answer to your questions is, yes they do.

#

Re:Plugins?

Posted by: Anonymous Coward on October 05, 2006 09:06 PM
totally agree - I surf without flash and all that crap and I get my work done just fine.

video over the internet I think is way over hyped.

#

custom "kernel"?

Posted by: Anonymous Coward on October 05, 2006 03:58 AM
Sadly inaccurate for reasons I won't even explain. I would expect this from Reuters, but Linux.com?

#

Re:custom "kernel"?

Posted by: Anonymous Coward on October 09, 2006 06:25 AM
If you recompile the kernel at least once you have yourself a "custom kernel". If their developer did this then the article makes perfect sense. From reading this reply it seems some people have never done that. I have, and it is a definite power trip.

#

Re:custom "kernel"?

Posted by: Administrator on October 05, 2006 11:37 PM
Fairly certain she was quoting the library guy, who probably had an odd grasp on the termonology for only-god-knows-why.

We both know Tina Gasperson knows what a kernel is...

#

Re:custom "kernel"?

Posted by: Administrator on October 09, 2006 06:06 AM
I guess this proves you don't have to know linux inside and out to decide it works for you. Way to go Amy for at least trying to understand what linux is all about. It also proves how stuck up some linux people are who throw away a great article for one uninformed but well intentioned quote. I'm no genius but I was able to infer that she meant to say "custom version". Please, people, cut some slack!

#

Re: Library system migrates from Linux

Posted by: Anonymous Coward on October 05, 2006 04:03 AM
"We're reading email and doing online banking."

Oh deary me...online banking at the library?! I guess it's better that they're using a Linux machine than a presumably compromised home computer running Windows.

Anyway, seems they got a great deal on this...I looked at the Groovix site and I couldn't figure out what things would cost from the info they had there. $25 for the software and $2000 for support is a fine deal.

#

Re: Library system migrates from Linux

Posted by: Anonymous Coward on October 09, 2006 08:00 AM
I just visited the Groovix site and their pricing is pretty clear to me. They charge $65/hour/4 incidents or $100/100 minutes/10 incidents (good for one year). I found that information under the "Store" tab. I'm sure the library negotiated a contract with incentives for Groovix.

#

What if ...

Posted by: Anonymous Coward on October 09, 2006 06:46 AM
What would happen to the Web if more educational institutions were to do this kind of thing? I'll tell you what. More internet sites would make sure they worked cross-platform and in any compliant browser instead of the bunch of lazies we have out there now. My hat's off to the Howard County public library for their support of open-source!

#

Re:custom "kernel"?

Posted by: Anonymous Coward on October 11, 2006 02:48 AM
I believe they are well-versed in customizing a kernel:



<a href="http://www.newsforge.com/article.pl?sid=04/05/03/1520209" title="newsforge.com">http://www.newsforge.com/article.pl?sid=04/05/03/<nobr>1<wbr></nobr> 520209</a newsforge.com>

#

This story has been archived. Comments can no longer be posted.



 
Tableless layout Validate XHTML 1.0 Strict Validate CSS Powered by Xaraya