Encouraging women in Linux
involves both learning what to do, and learning what to stop
doing. We'll present our ideas in "do" and "don't" pairs, since
having only a list of things to do or a list of things not to
do is not as helpful as having both. Some of these suggestions
may seem insultingly obvious to you personally, but for many
other people, they aren't obvious. Each of these suggestions is
based on multiple real-life encounters with people for whom
these ideas weren't obvious. Try not to dismiss any of the
ideas--these are real suggestions from real women, the women
you presumably want to attract to Linux. Also, most of these
suggestions are not gender-specific, and will help to attract
all types of people to Linux.
Sexist jokes are the number one
way to drive women out of any group, and they are more common
than many people realize. I have more than once heard a man
say that he doesn't make that kind of joke, and then hours or
minutes later, hear the same person make a joke about
pregnant women or PMS. Sometime he just doesn't realize that
he made a sexist joke, for example, "blonde jokes" are
actually "dumb women" jokes. Sometimes he tells me that it's
okay to make a sexist joke if it's true, or it's funny (funny
to whom?). What some people fail to realize is that jokes
about gender of any sort almost always make fun of women, and
will make most women angry, regardless of the context. It
doesn't help to first make a sexist joke about men and then
one about women.
You can argue that women
shouldn't be so sensitive (and I will disagree with you) but
even then, regardless of should or should not, your comments
and jokes are driving women away. If that's not what you
want, then don't make sexist jokes. If you're not sure if
your joke is sexist, find something else to say.
The next time you see someone
joking about women on your local mailing list or in person,
complain about it. It's difficult to do this without making
yourself a target for ridicule, but it's even more difficult
for a woman to do the same thing. Women keep silent when we
see sexist jokes because if we protest, we will immediately
be attacked for being over-sensitive, uptight, or a
"feminazi." (Note: NEVER use the term "feminazi." It
discredits all feminists, and trivializes the victims of the
Nazi Holocaust. Consider how ridiculous it sounds to call
people like Rush Limbaugh "male chauvinazis" and you may
understand why "feminazi" is so emotionally loaded.)
The best way to fight back
against sexist jokes is with humor. If someone replies to a
post about the technical achievements of a woman with "Is she
single?" reply with, "Gee, Jeff, no wonder YOU'RE still
single." Every time a woman sees a sexist joke or comment,
she feels angry, left out, and belittled. Every time a woman
sees a man stand up against this behavior, she feels included
and valued.
Imagine a bar or a pub full of
sports fans, fans of a game which you don't know much about
or like. Imagine that they're all taller and stronger than
you, speak in a language you only halfway understand, and
belittle anyone who isn't totally focused on their sport. Now
imagine that you walk into this bar, wearing a shirt that
says, "I AM NOT A FAN OF ANY SPORT." Just imagine it for a
minute. How would you feel? Nervous? Afraid? Different? Out
of place?
You begin to have a teeny-tiny
idea of what it's like to be the only woman in a large group
of men.
Keep that feeling of nervousness
in mind when you read the rest of this paragraph. When you
immediately make a sexual advance to a woman at a LUG or
online, you're making her feel like she's not part of the
community, like she's under attack, and like she is risking
being ostracized if she turns you down or offends you.
Remember, this isn't a friendly one-on-one situation where
she feels comfortable turning you down, she's surrounded by
the equivalent of the aforementioned huge sports fans. She's
trying to fit in and be part of the group, and by hitting on
her, you're cutting her out of the herd and isolating her
from the group. Women grow up with the constant fear and
awareness of being attacked by men, and as silly as it may
seem, it colors all her interactions, no matter how safe or
mundane they may seem to men.
Like any other human being, a
woman wants to have friends and be appreciated for who she
is. Every time she gets an email asking her on a date, she is
reminded that she isn't viewed as part of the group, but
instead as different, an object of desire, and is certainly
not being judged on her technical merit alone.
This may be hard to stomach, but
you need to not hit on women who show up for Linux events, at
least not right away. In all likelihood, you are NOT throwing
away your only chance at true love by not coming on to her
immediately, but you are throwing away your chance to have a
fun new member of the Linux community. And even if you still
think you're missing a chance at true love, keep in mind that
many women brave enough to show up at a LUG or your local
mailing list will frequently make the first move anyway. By
hitting on them at the first opportunity, you're scaring them
away, and you're also scaring away all the other women who
might have become interested if the first woman had
stayed.
This goes double for women you
meet over email or on IRC. You may think that your "Are you
single?" line is hysterically witty and suave, but she's
heard it a million times. Even if you're joking, even if you
already have a girlfriend or are married--don't do it.
When women aren't being hit on,
we're often being completely ignored, instead. This isn't any
better. Women new to a group often want the same things men
want - we want to feel welcomed, we want to talk about
subjects of mutual interest, we want to make friends. When a
woman says something, listen and respond in a friendly
manner. Start a conversation and find a topic you're both
interested in talking about. Don't assume that because she's
a woman, she has stereotypically female interests or
opinions, instead, keep an open mind and listen for clues
about what she is interested in. Most likely, she has
interests beyond hair, makeup, and movie stars if she's
involved in Linux.
Several women have complained
that all men seem to be able to talk about with them is why
women stay away from computers. While it's an important
issue, women would like to talk about something else most of
the time, and we would especially not like to be reminded of
how "weird" we are when we first join a group. Wait until
she's settled in and feels comfortable before bringing up the
subject if you're curious about it.
Instead of complaining about the
lack of women, start doing something about it. Take women's
complaints seriously (starting with this HOWTO), read the
studies on why women avoid computers, math, and science in
general, and find ways that you can help encourage women. Be
encouraging and supportive when other people discuss the
reasons why women are being driven out of computing. If you
have the opportunity, try to mentor women. Mentoring means
guiding, encouraging, and counseling someone in their
education and career. Not everyone is capable of mentoring,
and it's difficult to find compatible mentors and mentees,
but when it does work out, the results can be spectacular.
Don't, however, think of mentoring as a way to find a
girlfriend - all a mentor gets out of the relationship is
reflected glory from your student and the joy of watching
another person grow.
Don't assume that all women like
cooking, sewing, and babies, and are at the LUG or on the
mailing list only because their boyfriend, son, or husband
are interested in Linux. One woman says that every time
someone in her LUG explained something to her, they would use
an analogy to cooking or babies, assuming that those were the
subjects she was most familiar with. Don't assume we aren't
interested in cars, math, fighter jets, or robotics. Don't
assume that we don't know how to compile a kernel--I
personally know at least fifteen women who can compile their
own kernels and several of those also write kernel code. If
you're lucky, one of them will show up to your LUG or mailing
list, and you wouldn't want to insult her by assuming she
couldn't even install her own machine. Don't assume that she
got interested in computers because she liked to chat or send
instant messages. Women are about as likely to cuss as
men--don't do a double-take if you cuss in front of a woman.
If she's read any of the kernel code (notably arch/sparc/),
she's heard of the word "fuck" before.
As much as you can, act like the
women in your group are just normal people, because we are
just normal people. Some people complain, "Women want to be
treated just like normal people, but then they tell me not to
make sexist jokes around them! That's a paradox!" Well, if
you define "normal people" as "the men I usually hang out
with," then it is a paradox. If you include women in your
definition of "normal people," and then treat normal people
in a fair and respectful way, then women don't require any
special treatment.
If you're still unsure of how to treat women, try the
following: Be friendly but not overbearing, be casual, start
conversations the way you normally do, move on when the
conversation is over. If you spend most of your time around a
very specific subset of the male population, you will have to
change your behavior to some degree, but this is just as true
as if you were talking to a man from a totally different
background. If you find that you have to heavily modify your
behavior in order to not offend women, you should consider
changing your behavior in all circumstances. No one is fooled
if you simply stop making sexist jokes when women are around
but continue to make them when (you think) women aren't
around.
Women have much lower
self-confidence than men on average, and will generally judge
themselves far more harshly than any outsider. Compliments
help improve her self-confidence, which in turn keeps her
interested in the subject. If she believes that she's not
good at Linux, she'll probably stop working on Linux.
The following are some
guidelines for complimenting anyone:
-
Be sincere and truthful. If you really think her program
is an ugly piece of garbage, don't tell her that you
admire its syntactic beauty. Find something you can
honestly admire and compliment that.
-
Be specific. "You're good at Linux," is meaningless, "You
always know which distribution to recommend," is specific
and therefore meaningful.
-
Be appropriate. Don't compliment a kernel developer on
installing Linux. Don't compliment a gimp developer on
her use of layers. Be sure that your compliment actually
reflects a significant accomplishment rather than
demonstrating your ignorance of her level of expertise.
-
Compare to yourself. If she learned bash scripting more
quickly than you did, tell her so. Say, "Wow, you learned
bash scripting after X months. It took me 2*X months to
learn that." Or if she made a silly compilation mistake,
tell her about your worst compilation mistake. When she
learns that her mistakes are not unusual, she'll feel
better.
-
Compliment before you criticize. If you do have a
constructive piece of criticism, it's a good idea to
start out by telling her what she did right.
-
Compliment and don't criticize. Don't always follow a
compliment with a criticism. More often, compliment her
and be done with it.
-
Don't brag. Saying, out of the blue, "She can compile her
own kernel!" and beaming fondly upon her is not
complimentary, it's bragging about her abilities as if
you are responsible in some way for her success. Parents
are especially prone to bragging. Pointing out her
expertise in an unobtrusive and subtle manner is much
better - "Oh, well, if you have a question about kernel
compilation, she might be able to help you better than I
can." When someone points out my capabilities in this
manner, it's indescribably wonderful.
You almost certainly shouldn't compliment her on her hair,
her face, her body, or her sweet temperament. If she's
interested in Linux, she is, by definition, a geek, and
probably wants to be complimented on her intelligence,
abilities, and hard work. Compliment her on installing Linux
for the first time, on her customized desktop, on her
intelligent and interesting questions during the last
meeting. A compliment on anything else is inappropriate and
will be seen as a sexual advance (because it almost always
is), and will make her feel more uncomfortable and less
confident.