Things I like about KDE4.

Posted by: Sean Tilley

Tagged in: Plasma , Phonon , Oxygen , Kwin , KDE4 , KDE

Sean Tilley

       There's been quite a bit of hubub about the KDE project ever since the 4.0 release last year. Critics have slammed the 4.0 series repeatedly, citing the mentality of "Well, it's not good enough to be a full release.". Between the poor publicity, the crashes in Plasma, and the still-developing early features, KDE was definitely not having a good time. Developer blogs were plastered with hateful comments, and one of my favorite devs Aaron Seigo had to temporarily shut down his blog.

       However, for all the bad rap that the 4.0 series received, KDE has grown wonderfully. With the upcoming releases of KDE 4.3, Plasma has become a rock-solid desktop environment. Sites such as KDE-Look.org have dozens of Plasmoids and Plasma themes ready for desktop user consumption. Major headway is being done on theming, as new community artists continue to contribute new variations of the existing theme engines. (This user in particular is using the "Introducing KDE4" Bespin configuration theme)

       With all said and done, I would like to bullet-point a few things that I really love about KDE. After tinkering around with the system and setting up a build environment (mainly for building Plasmoid binaries), I have this to say:

 -Plasma gets the job done nowadays.  It's not the crashy, spiteful desktop of the 4.0 days. Also, many of the themes and plasmoids that have come out are just incredible. As of writing this, I'm using the Daisy plasmoid for Window management with an Xbar on a panel up top. All with a Glassified theme. Looks spiffy!

 -Cmake, the build system for KDE applications, is a fantastc piece of work. I've always had trouble with the build-essentials packages when compiling Gnome apps. I have to hand it to Gnome packaging teams, that stuff can be a real pain in the rear if you don't know the dependencies! At the very least, Cmake is great about letting me know about a missing dependency, or an error in the CMakelists.txt, or etc. It's becoming a real joy just to find the most obscure experimental apps on KDE-Apps.org, and build them to see what they do. 

-Kwin is nice and snappy. I've loved the simple effects that ship with it, but it's a real lifesaver for when something goes awry when  I build experimental Plasmoids that crash Plasma. You can just flick to a running terminal. Better yet, you can just run Yakuake and make things even easier. 

 -The KDEArtwork package gets better with every subsequent release. Oxygen becomes more and more beautiful and polished, and the user-submitted wallpapers that make it into the release package are top-notch. While I usually end up just switching to the wallpapers I've always used, the KDE wallpapers anymore look better than a lot of professional pictures done for those Other operating systems.

-The Developers are so in touch with the community. One of my favorite things is moseying over to Planet KDE and reading the latest experiments the devs are up to. There's always a fascinating screenshot or mockup to explain a concept. 

-KRunner is a superb app for quickly launching anything you need to. It really reminds me of QuickSilver, which was one of my favorite OSX addons ever.

 -The Folder View/Desktop view merged paradigm blows me away. I like having my Desktop function like an actual desktop, but I love using a folder view to check files in my documents. With the simplicity of dragging and dropping, Plasma has really gotten intuitive.

-Phonon's graphical configuration frontend is much more comprehensible to me than Pulse Audio Device Chooser's numerous dialogs. Out of the box, it just works with my music player, web browser, games, etc.

-As a final note, I really appreciate that the Rekonq Project has finally been officially integrated in the KDE Project. For those of you who don't know, Rekonq is built off of Trolltech's Qt Webkit example browser. It sports a clean interface, and the webkit engine is not only ridiculously fast, it renders things properly! I've always had problems with Konqueror, even with the Webkit Kpart. Hopefully, this will open up more options for KDE-compatible browsers.

Comments (4)Add Comment
Joao Goulart
Kde4
written by Joao Goulart, August 25, 2009
I understand your point, but since kde4 I am using gnome to get my job done. Until now I can't get do my job with kde4 as I used to in kde3. My fault perhaps, but kde4 is still too hard for people not conecerned about fancy screens and other "windows" things.
DDevine
KDE 4 is maturing very fast - forget the older 4.x releases
written by DDevine, August 29, 2009
I don't have any idea why you would have any trouble getting used to KDE 4 or even WORKING day to day. It is just KDE 3 but totally different stuff under the hood and some nice eye candy - don't over complicate things! Yes, it was hard to get work done in the 4.0 and 4.1 releases because of the constant crashing but they were development releases that had big bold letting saying "not for daily use!"

4.2 was the first release that was really usable - 4.3 is bloody great. I think it is easier to live, work and play in KDE 4 than in ANY other environment. Some people get put off by the new K menu - if they just spent a day using it they would find now useful, quick and easy it is compared to the slow and labor intensive menus (think KDE 3 or Windows XP). Still can't get used to the menu? Right click the K icon and then select "Switch to Classic Menu Style" and quit your bitching.

The folder view widgets are a real time saver and probably my favourite thing about KDE 4. The desktop is not just a representation of your Desktop folder anymore - you can have multiple folders displayed in a box on your desktop. A real time saver, usability enhancement and productivity booster.
Joao Goulart
Kde4
written by Joao Goulart, September 01, 2009
No problem. I've just get used to Gnome.
For my needs on a real job on a real world, using Linux on desktop for the last 5 years, Gnome is just fine.
But I've heard for a lot of people the same complains about kde4.
It's not just my opinion, try a search engine with "kde4 sucks", and you will see my point.
Zanpaktou
kde3 sucked!
written by Zanpaktou, September 23, 2009
Everything I find if I search google for "kde4 sucks" Involves involuntary childish rants by people that can't spell or that would have their own foot in their own mouths if they were saying the same things today. I think that the kde devs should probably have put "NOT FOR DAILY USE!" In big red capital letters on the development releases but most of these trolls would still have downloaded/Installed/Complained about kde 4 anyway because that would be their mentality and or their prerogative.
It didn't help that some distributors were shipping kde 4 development releases as a default desktop way before it was announced as ready for the masses to adopt.
It also did not help that plenty of selfish trolls harshly criticised and got personal about kde 4 test releases. Some developers left the project because of the abuse they received and fair play to them too! Why should they create code for ungrateful people who have no ability or will to contribute to improve kde 4?
It's also pure troll bait discussing kde with some gnome users. I mean Jesus please! Just get a grip. The rebel alliance destroyed the death star.
I have my suspicions that maybe some of the trolls with flame throwers aimed at the kde devs were die hard gnome fan boys; and they were seriously worried by the press kde 4 was generating at the time. Maybe they thought that gnome would start to look like an inferior desktop in comparison to the new features being implemented in kde 4?

I use kde 4 every day. I've used kde 4 every day since kde 4.1 was released and if the kde project hadn't pushed as hard as they did to make kde 4 the number one Linux desktop choice it is today, then I would have continued to use xfce.
Why?
kde3 sucked!

I did't like anything about kde3 and I am very glad that the kde developers were wise enough to drop support for it so that the developers didn't waste any time further developing it. I ended up preferring xfce and icewm to kde in the dark distant days of version 3. I didn't like the icons, the qt application widget layouts looked like a fake Chinese copy of Win 2000 and it was slow compared to kde 4. The only thing I liked in kde3 was konqueror (As a concept,) it however failed as a web browser (Poor rendering and incomplete plugin support) And wasn't really a feature complete file manager.

The main reasons the kde developers had for starting kde 4 development have been proven to be completely justified.
Nepomuk (For those people who believe that semantics can work. Not me.)
Solid & phonon (Hardware and multimedia frameworks that make things simpler.)
qt4 (Much, much, much better than qt3. There is absolutely no doubt in that.)
Plasma (superkaramba never worked as expected here and plasma widgets are far more flexible and easier to code.)

So yeah, kde ROCKS! smilies/grin.gif

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy