– By Grant Gross –

Two products, one in its infancy and one offered by an established company, aim to do away with the popular option of dual booting to run Windows applications on your Linux machine.

VMware Workstation for Linux, which allows users to run multiple virtual computers on a single PC, now has competition, with members of the Plex86 project announcing last week that they have successfully run Windows 95 on top of Linux Mandrake. Attacking the issue of running Windows programs from another angle is the Wine project, which doesn’t run Windows, but allows Windows programs to run on Linux and Unix. There’s also the low-cost Win4Lin, which allows users to boot Windows 95/98 as an application running under the X Window System on Linux.

Reza Malekzadeh, VMware’s director of market relations, says he respects the Plex86 project, but he doesn’t seem too worried when asked about the advantages of VMware. VMware offers versions of the product with Linux, Windows NT, or Windows 2000 as the host operating system, he says, and each can run a variety of OSes as guest environments, including DOS, Windows 3.1, Windows 95, Windows 98, Windows NT, Windows 2000, FreeBSD, and Solaris for Intel.

“VMware Workstation has been shipping since May 1999 and has over 500,000 users now,” he adds. “We feel the technology and product have been widely used and proven. The product has a good reputation of stability and reliability.”

Says one fan, who bought a copy of VMware Workstation 2.0 for Linux at the Atlanta Linux Showcase: “When set up properly, this Linux product is the coolest thing since the Palm Pilot. No more re-boots to check Windoze based stuff.”

Backers of both projects tout the “virtual machines” concept as an alternative to dual-booting Linux and Windows, and VMware has marketed its Linux version, which has been sold since May 1999, as a tool for developers, QA testers, and others who have to test applications in more than one operating system environment. But the virtual machines products are also finding fans among users who just want to run an application or two that aren’t available in Linux.

“Dual-booting is a pain right in the ol’ arse,” says Kevin Lawton, technical lead of the Plex86 project. “Most people who I have talked to have a small handful of Windows apps that they want to run on occasion. Otherwise, they’d wouldn’t even bother ever booting Windows or keeping the partition around.

“Generally, users just want to punch a button on their desktop, do something in Windows, then quit,” Lawton adds. ” Shutting down and rebooting a machine twice takes a bite out of time
and productivity and is frustrating.”

Linux users will benefit the most from Plex86, he adds. “Let’s face it, there are an enormous amount of people who are waiting for Linux to offer them the ability to use their current codebase of Windows apps. Not always because there is no Linux counterpart – but sometimes because using the Windows programs is a company mandate/standard.”

Right now, Plex86 can run Windows 95, MSDOS, FreeDOS, and Linux as guest OSes on top of its Linux host. The next goals, Lawton says, include supporting more OSes as guests, including Windows 98 and NT, and increasing the performance of the program. “There are many things to do to plex86 to increase performance,” he says. “Up until now, I’ve used the design philosophy of getting things working before optimizing.

“Before we can offer something that is worthy of serving most users’ needs, we need some time to fill things out and add some performance enhancements,” he adds, “though, at the rate this project is progressing, that may be measured more in weeks than months.”

Lawton and fans of Plex86 says its big advantages are it’s free and Open Source, compared to the proprietary VMware Workstation, which costs $299 for an electronic version and $329 for the packaged version. Academic pricing is $99 for electronic and $129 for packaged.

“Plex86 is an Open Source project,” Lawton says. “Because of this, we can export things such as a good debugging interface, to projects which find them extremely useful. But proprietary software companies may well not offer these features, out of fear of exposing some internal architecture, or simply because they don’t want to bother supporting them for a small number of users who desire them.”

NewsForge editors read and respond to comments posted on our discussion page.

Australian IT reports: “Microsoft and the computer industry should bet their futures on XML, chairman Bill Gates told the Comdex trade show last week. Delivering his keynote in Las Vegas, Mr. Gates said Extensible Markup Language mixed the fundamentals of peer-to-peer computing with servers.”

“As ADSL continues to attract bad press for slow rollout, high prices and limited range, broadband wireless has been heralded as a quick, cheap alternative to getting the UK wired to broadband. E-minister Patricia Hewitt looked forward to a “competitive” auction and anticipated its roll out would benefit both businesses and the “whole economy”. The reality has been somewhat different.” Full story at ZDNet UK News.

Sensei wrote in to tell us about Danny DiPaolo’s article on Linuxnewbie.org: Customizing vim. Designed for “anyone who really loves their vim and wants to make it even better,” the piece includes plenty of hints and tips to get the most out of this venerable text editor.

The Register reports “Compaq has been slapped with a patent infringement lawsuit demanding at least $60 million in damages. The patents cover the compression of video data, and the plaintiff is a consortium of seven companies, including consumer electronics operations JVC and Matsushita.”

osOpinion Webmaster Kelly McNeill stopped by to tell us about a review of Linux-Mandrake 7.2 on that site. “Mike” writes: “I’ve always maintained that Linux could be a useable desktop OS if some of the development community worked toward that end. The Gnome and KDE people obviously feel the same way. It now takes fewer mouse clicks to install Linux than any version of MS Windows and, hey, it works right outta the box.”

Looking for a friendlier way to tell your users the document they’re looking for isn’t available? Zez.org’s Paul Kenneth Egell-Johnsen offers a few tips for making a more informative 404 error page with Apache. Thanks to NewsForge reader pkej for the pointer.

A post at LWN.net details two recently discovered issues with the Common UNIX Printing System’s access control and network behavior.

ZDNet’s Jason Brooks comments on the future of Windows and its alternatives: “The wicked Windows 9x witch is nearly dead. Sometime next year, a tornado of marketing hype will emerge from Redmond to drop a house on Microsoft’s marquee product. And, as its feet shrivel, I’ll not shed a tear.”

“Next year, Palm will begin offering a back-end platform to support enterprise applications with integrated application services tailored for individual business users. Through the platform, corporations will be able to allow employees access to networked applications through their Palm personal digital assistants.” Full report at ZDNet eWEEK.