August 31, 2000

Bring me the head of an AbiWord developer

Author: JT Smith

By Emmett Plant
NewsForge Columnist

OK, I'm writing my column for the second time due to technical
difficulties. Tension runs high, and I'm already well past deadline -- a
place I don't like to be. I try as hard as possible to make deadlines, and
it makes me mad when technology fails. Bring me the head of an AbiWord
developer.It goes far beyond that, of course. I can only hold AbiWord partially
responsible. AbiWord (as it turns out) is a pre-beta piece of software
that needs to be tested a lot more before it gets shipped with a Linux
distribution. That's cool. The folks that make AbiWord should say
something like, "Hey, for God's sake, don't ship this. It ain't ready."

But guess who shipped AbiWord? Red Hat. I'm running on a Red Hat box at
the moment, and AbiWord shipped with Red Hat 6.2, as far as I can
tell. Either that or it shipped with Helix GNOME, which I run on this
machine. So, bring me the head of a Red Hat guy or Helix's Nat Friedman,

If you want Linux to have a "ready for prime time" look and feel, don't, I
repeat, don't ship it with software that shouldn't be used. The
version number states that it's a "preview release." It should say,
"For the love of God, don't use this software ever. It can not be
trusted, it can not be leaned upon. It is not your friend."

Okay, it's a "preview release," and I should say, "Hey, this is a
preview release, maybe I shouldn't run this, or my work will disappear
when it crashes, and I'll cry." But I don't, because I'm a trusting
fool. I deserve what I get. But I understand Open Source software, I
understand how alpha software works (or in this case, doesn't work). I'm
an understanding soul.

The problem is, Mr. Experimentor wants to do stuff with Linux right out of
the box. Mr. Experimentor has never even used Linux before. You think
he's gonna give a damn if it says "preview release" on the splash
screen? Not a chance. He doesn't even read the EULA when the OS is being
installed. He doesn't even read the instructions on his VCR. The reason he
doesn't is because he feels he doesn't have to. Why should he? He starts
Windows, types something up in Word, saves it, prints it. He's on his
merry way.

Mr. Experimentor will have the exact same experience that I did, only he'll lose a 22-page article on how great Linux is. He will leave
Linux, he will never come back, and he will tell all of his friends
exactly how bad Linux sucks. He will become a Microsoft slave because the
only real alternative he's been given featured a word processor that
killed his work dead. This is a sad day.

People who package software need to act responsibly, no matter who they're
working for. I'm begging, I'm pleading. Please don't let Mr. Experimentor
get away. He's the guy that will be paying all of our bills once Linux
proves itself to be ready for the desktop big time. Mr. Experimentor
represents the Packard Bell-using, AOL-dialing guy that the desktop
developers just can't get enough of. Do not let him get away. Don't
package stuff until it's ready. If it's not ready, do not ship it. Can I
say that enough? Probably not.

See you in seven.


  • News
Click Here!